• About
  • Contacts
IR Web Report
  • Latest Posts
  • Categories
    • Web Disclosure
    • Annual Reports
    • Quarterly Reporting
    • Presentations
    • Social Media
    • IR Law
    • Governance
    • Shareholder Services
    • Video
    • Mobile
Browse: Home / Is Shareholder.com client breaching SEC privacy rules?


Is Shareholder.com client breaching SEC privacy rules?

By Dominic Jones on July 10, 2007

  • Tweet

APPLIED Micro Circuits Corporation (NASDAQ: AMCC), one of the first companies to make use of the new e-Proxy process, is using cookies to identify and track people using the website hosting its annual report and proxy statement.

Under the Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) rule for the voluntary e-Proxy process, “a registrant or its agent shall maintain the Internet Web site on which it posts its proxy materials in a manner that does not infringe on the anonymity of a person accessing such Web site.”

However, AMCC‘s website uses a website tracking system that uses cookies to identify investors and then track their movements on its site. The tracking tools are provided by Shareholder.com, a subsidiary of Nasdaq Stock Market Inc. (NASDAQ:NDAQ). More than 100 companies currently use the tracking system.

The types of information companies collect is illustrated by the screenshot below, which is a sample of an individual website activity report that Shareholder.com clients can view using its “Pinpoint Intelligence” system. It shows the name of a website user and what materials they viewed on the company’s website, and when they did so.

screenshot

The concern is that by comparing website activity with voting returns, companies could establish when and how investors voted their proxies. This could be used to compromise the vote or otherwise infringe on shareholders’ anonymity.

The tracking is typically not disclosed to investors. It works by loading a cookie, a small text file, on users’ hard drives when they register to access information or services on the site. The investor’s name is then associated with the cookie and the company can track and store information on what the person does on its website.

To illustrate the system, I registered to access AMCC’s RSS feeds using a fictitious name, Jack Sprat. This is shown in the screenshot below.

AMCC registration screen

After registering, I navigated to AMCC’s proxy statement on its website. I then checked my browser to see what cookies were installed while I was viewing the proxy statement. One of the cookies clearly was being used to identify me as Jack Sprat. This is shown in the screenshot below.

Screenshot of cookie information
The above image shows the cookie identifying me as Jack Sprat while I was viewing AMCC’s proxy statement on its website. The URL for the proxy statement is highlighted in yellow at the top of the picture.

Based on my admittedly non-legal reading of the SEC’s e-Proxy rule, what AMCC is doing is a breach of the rules. If anyone has an alternative viewpoint, I’d be grateful if they would use the comment form below or email me directly.


Related items on this topic:

AMERCO’s shareholder forum, e-proxy (July 11, 2007)

My bad experience with first e-proxy notice (July 04, 2007)

SEC to go back on e-proxy usability? (June 15, 2007)

E-proxy: do it for love, not money (June 14, 2007)


Dominic Jones

Dominic Jones (bio) created IR Web Report in 2001. He is a consultant to leading public companies and investor relations service providers worldwide. You can contact him via the contacts page.

Posted in Articles | Tagged e-proxy, feeds, law, nasdaq, privacy, rss, SEC, securities, shareholder.com, usability

« Previous Next »

Search the Site

Latest Stories

  • Survey finds social media gap between investors, companies
  • SEC’s social media guidance has devil in details
  • Crisis investor relations in the age of social media
  • Private meetings undermine fair disclosure, study finds
  • What makes a good annual report?
  • CEO pushes Reg FD limits on Twitter
  • For IROs, XBRL errors a wake-up call

Get Our Free Email Newsletter

Close
Note: We don't sell or rent our email list. Unsubscribe instructions come with each email.

Full Disclosure

All articles on IR Web Report are unpaid editorial. We do not charge a fee to outside contributors. Sponsors or advertisers are not automatically entitled to become contributors or receive editorial coverage. We accept contributors based on their individual expertise and experience. Contributors are required to disclose when they write about or refer to any company with which they have a business relationship, either directly or indirectly. If you believe that any contributor or IR Web Report is not living up this policy, please contact us or leave a comment on the relevant post. Editorial integrity is important to us and we take all complaints seriously.

Site Map

  • Home
  • Terms of Use
  • IR News
  • About
  • Contacts

Archives

  • 2013
  • 2011
  • 2010
  • 2009
  • 2008
  • 2007
  • 2006
  • 2005
  • 2004
  • 2003
  • 2002
  • 2001

About IR Web Report

Founded in 2001, we are the world's leading source of information about online investor relations communications. Our core philosophy is that investors' needs must come first or companies' online communications efforts will fail to be effective. More about us

Follow @irwebreport
Feed Subscribe to feed

Copyright © 2001 - 2018 IR Web Reporting International Inc. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and our Privacy & Cookie Use Policy.